Sid Mehta Works
Broken and Beautiful

Broken and Beautiful

285+ answers in a New York public interaction: what feels beautiful, what feels broken?

  • Role Solo
  • Year 2024

Project highlights

285+

public responses

2 days

interface build

NYC

public interaction

Overview

Built and ran a public interaction piece in New York that gathered 285+ anonymous answers to one question: what feels beautiful, and what feels broken.

Research · Public ArtSolo · Self Initiated

Insight

285+ responses. 15 street interviews. A quiet thread of human thoughts, gathered in parks and on phones across New York City.

A Reddit thread: places to cry in NYC.

Reddit thread: places to cry in NYC
Research references

What I wanted the space to feel like: quiet enough to think, open enough not to feel alone.

Space reference: what it should feel like
The cardboard prototype, the responses plotted by emotion, and a sketch of the stand on a Manhattan street
In the city's rush, we often feel small. This space is an oasis, a break from it all

A stop sign already means something. Redeployed not as a warning, but as an invitation.

The stand

Moment of truth. Union Square Park.

I had an idea to create an online, Reddit-like site to store stories.

Broken and Beautiful branding

Each poster a small bet on which stranger stops long enough to scan.

QR code poster variations
Poster variations

Responses coming in. What felt broken, and what felt beautiful.

Union Square subway.

Words people kept using, given visual shape. Not illustrating, just looking.

An image of what we carry without knowing others carry it too.

Fifteen strangers. One question. Here are four of them.

Russell
John
Karis
Tsing
Reflection

I built the interface in two days and spent the rest of the project reading what people submitted. The responses were more specific than I expected. Not “my grandmother” but “my grandmother at 3am.” That specificity kept appearing across hundreds of entries: people writing for themselves but somehow writing for each other. In public research, the prompt created the opening. The artifact recorded what people chose to share.

Back to top
Next project Encoded An AR exhibition at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, reinterpreting the American Wing th... Back to top